How to Choose the Perfect Engagement Ring

How to Choose the Perfect Engagement Ring

The Complete Guide to Choosing an Engagement Ring

Choosing an engagement ring is one of the most meaningful purchases you’ll ever make, and it can also feel overwhelming. With so many options in diamonds, gemstones, settings, and metals, where do you even start?

Whether you’re planning a surprise proposal or shopping together as a couple, this complete guide will walk you through every key decision so you can choose the perfect engagement ring with confidence.

Step 1: Diamond or Gemstone?

Choosing between a diamond and a gemstone ultimately comes down to personal style, symbolism, and priorities.

Diamonds are celebrated for their brilliance, durability, and timeless appeal, making them a classic choice. Gemstones like sapphire, emerald, and ruby, on the other hand, offer vibrant color and individuality, often at a more budget-friendly price point.

If you’re drawn to tradition and lasting sparkle, a diamond may be the way to go. If you want something bold or unique, a gemstone can feel deeply personal and one-of-a-kind.

Option A: Diamonds & the “4 Cs”

If you’re leaning toward a diamond the most traditional and popular choice, it helps to understand the 4 Cs, a global grading system established by the GIA (Gemological Institute of America).

Here’s a quick overview (you can explore our full 4 Cs guide for more detail):

  1. Cut
    How well the diamond is shaped. This is the most important factor affecting brilliance and sparkle.

    • Grades: Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair

    • Tip: Prioritize cut for maximum sparkle.

  2. Clarity
    Refers to internal or external imperfections (called inclusions or blemishes).

    • Grades range from Flawless (FL) to Included (I1–I3).

    • Tip: Many diamonds with lower clarity grades, like Slightly Included (SI1 or SI2), still appear “eye-clean,” meaning inclusions aren’t visible without magnification.

  3. Color
    Measures how colorless a diamond is.

    • Grades range from D (colorless) to Z (light yellow or brown).

    • Tip: Near-colorless grades (G–H) often offer the best balance of beauty and value.

  4. Carat
    The diamond’s weight, not its physical size.

    • Larger carat weight usually means a visually bigger diamond.

    • A 1-carat center stone is a popular benchmark.

    • Tip: Small differences in carat weight can significantly affect price.

Option B: Gemstones, A Modern Alternative

While diamonds are timeless, more couples today are choosing alternative gemstones — for ethical reasons, budget, or simply personal taste.

Gemstones often shine best in non-traditional settings. For a deeper look, explore our Gemstone Guide, but here are some stunning options to consider:

  1. Moissanite — Brilliant, durable (second only to diamonds), lab-created, eco-friendly, and far more affordable.

  2. Sapphire — Exceptionally hard and available in many colors, not just royal blue.

  3. Morganite — Soft blush pink with a romantic, feminine appeal; pairs beautifully with rose gold.

  4. Emerald — Deep green with vintage charm, slightly more delicate.

  5. Ruby — Bold red color, dramatic and durable; looks striking in yellow or white gold.

  6. Aquamarine — Ocean-blue hue, light and breezy, more affordable, perfect for minimalist styles.

Step 2: Choose the Shape

The shape of your stone defines the ring’s character and style.

  • Round Brilliant: Classic and timeless.

  • Oval: Elegant and elongates the finger.

  • Princess (Square): Modern and bold.

  • Emerald: Vintage glamour with step-cut facets.

  • Pear: Romantic and distinctive.

  • Cushion: Soft square with rounded corners for a vintage-modern feel.

Step 3: Pick a Setting

The setting holds the center stone and sets the tone for your ring’s look. Popular choices include:

  1. Solitaire – A single diamond on a simple band; timeless and minimalist.

  2. Halo – A central stone surrounded by smaller diamonds for extra sparkle.

  3. Hidden Halo – Diamonds beneath the center stone for subtle, side-view sparkle.

  4. Pavé – Small diamonds set close together on the band for a glittering effect.

  5. Bezel – The stone is encased in metal; sleek, secure, and modern.

  6. Three-Stone – A center stone flanked by two smaller stones, symbolizing past, present, and future.

  7. Cathedral – Metal arches lift the stone, adding height and elegance.

  8. Tension – The stone appears suspended between the band’s ends; bold and contemporary.

  9. East-West – The stone is set horizontally for a chic, unexpected twist.

Step 4: Select the Metal

The metal you choose affects both style and durability.

1. Gold (Yellow, White, or Rose)
Gold is a timeless, versatile choice that comes in different tones and purities:

  • Yellow Gold: Warm and traditional; flatters warm skin tones.

  • White Gold: Modern and bright; needs rhodium plating to retain color.

  • Rose Gold: Romantic and trendy; complements all skin tones.

Karat (K) measures purity (not to be confused with diamond carat weight):

  • 14K Gold (58.5% pure): More durable and affordable.

  • 18K Gold (75% pure): Richer in color but slightly softer.

2. Platinum
Platinum is a premium metal known for its durability and natural white luster.

  • Naturally white with a soft, silvery tone.

  • Extremely durable and hypoallergenic.

  • Doesn’t require replating and maintains its color over time.

Step 5: Setting a Budget

There’s no universal rule for how much to spend the old “three months’ salary” idea is outdated. The best budget is one that feels right for you and reflects your financial priorities.

Smart ways to maximize your budget:

  • Decide what matters most (size, sparkle, or quality).

  • Consider lab-grown diamonds identical to natural diamonds but far more affordable.

  • Choose stones just under milestone weights (e.g., 0.90ct instead of 1.00ct).

  • Explore less common shapes like pear or a cushion for better value.

  • Start simple and upgrade later.

  • Consider alternative stones like moissanite or sapphire.

At Saint Stone, we believe in full transparency. When you design your ring with us, you’ll see exactly how each choice affects the price.

Remember: The value of an engagement ring isn’t in the price tag it’s in the love and intention behind it. Whether your budget is $1,000 or $10,000, the best ring is the one that captures your story and fits your lifestyle.

Step 6: Find the Right Ring Size

If you’re planning a surprise proposal, getting the right size can be tricky, but it’s not impossible. Depending on the ring’s design, resizing is often simple. For tips on how to secretly find your partner’s ring size, check out our guide on Shopping Together vs. Surprise Engagements.

Final Thoughts

The perfect engagement ring doesn’t need to follow trends or rules; it just needs to feel right for your relationship. Think about what they wear, what makes them smile, and what best reflects your story together.

At Saint Stone, we’re here to guide you every step of the way.
Book a free virtual appointment with no obligation, and let us help you find (or create) the perfect engagement ring.

Back to Journal